Claude says:Manchester Orchestra's third album is a concept record built around Andy Hull's own questioning at 23 — marriage, faith, sex, all tangled together until even he couldn't always tell which one he was addressing. Released in 2011 through their own Favorite Gentlemen imprint, it debuted at number 21 on the Billboard 200 and earned the band their strongest critical reception yet. You gave it a shot in late 2012 and have only circled back twice since — most recently in 2024, over a decade later.