Claude says:The Fray's 2012 pivot toward darker, more cinematic rock found you keeping "Heartbeat" on repeat—that track's anxiety and urgency became your go-to during whatever 2012 had in store. Scars & Stories never quite became a daily player, but you've drifted back to it enough over the years to know it's the one where they stopped trying to be the feel-good alternative rock band everyone expected.