Claude says:Panic! at the Disco's second album veered hard into Beatles-indebted baroque pop and string arrangements in 2008, trading emo theatrics for something almost quaint and wistful. You picked it up early the next year and kept drifting back to "Nine in the Afternoon" — that one's stuck around while the rest of the album comes and goes, which makes sense for a track that feels lighter and more genuinely playful than the heavier drama surrounding it.